Sometimes a game rolls along just fine, everything calm, until one unexpected play turns baseball into straight-up comedy. That is how we get the weirdest endings to a baseball game, moments so bizarre they can leave even the most seasoned broadcasters completely stunned.
Since the diamond never runs out of surprises, these endings prove that creativity in sports truly has no limits. Each story is a reminder that even if you know every rule, baseball can still hit you with a plot twist that is as strange as it is unforgettable.
The 6 Weirdest Endings to a Baseball Game
Before stepping onto the field, it helps to remember that what you’re about to see isn’t fiction. It’s a curated selection of moments where the weirdest endings to a baseball game remind us that this sport can be chaotic and charming, absurd yet unbelievably entertaining.
The catcher who ended the game by getting in the way
In 2025, Phillies vs. Red Sox delivered a gem. The catcher brushed the opponent’s bat and, just like that, the runner on third scored automatically. No drama, no swing, no nothing. It was such an anticlimactic finish it felt like someone wanted to head home early and lock the stadium behind them.
The unassisted triple play
Back in 2009, Eric Bruntlett decided that getting three outs for the price of one sounded like a bargain. He snagged a line drive, stepped on second, and tagged the runner passing by. Game over. Fans needed more time to process what had happened than Bruntlett needed to pull it off. Efficiency at its finest.
The saddest automatic strike in history
In 2023, the newly introduced pitch clock showed off its personality by ending a game on its own. Cal Conley wasn’t set in time, the umpire called strike three, and everyone stared in disbelief, as if a smart speaker had just announced the end of the match. No arguments, just pure confusion.
A balk that turned out the lights
A balk already baffles half the ballpark, so having a game end on one is next-level weird. Back in 2018, Dylan Floro twitched on the mound, the ump rang him up, and the runner on third jogged in for the win. Only baseball delivers chaos this perfectly.
Babe Ruth’s most unexpected ending
During the 1926 World Series, Babe Ruth tried to steal second to tie the game. The result? He was thrown out with ease. That ended Game 7. A finish worthy of a legendary meme: the world’s greatest hitter losing a championship because of an ill-timed steal attempt.
Obstruction decides a World Series
In 2013, Allen Craig tumbled over Middlebrooks on his way to the plate, got tagged, and everyone figured he was out… until the umps called obstruction and awarded him the run. Boston lost like a glitch had taken over the game—weird, messy, and totally collectible.
Throughout all these cases, fans still refer to them as some of the weirdest endings to a baseball game, the kind you have to watch twice just to confirm they really happened. Which bizarre baseball ending would you put at the top of your list?
